ReadingResearchRadarInvestment framework
Sign in / Sign up
AllTechnologyProductsInvestingPublic marketsOther

Reading

2026-11-03100 posts

Refresh

The Profit Paradox of Google's AI Search: Heavier Investment, Thinner Margins

Material
2026-11-02 14:35 GMT+8

Alphabet delivered a seemingly contradictory performance report for the third quarter: total revenue reached $127.6 billion, up approximately 25% year-over-year; Google Cloud revenue doubled to $30.7 billion, with an operating margin rising to 36%. However, on the day following the earnings release, the stock price plummeted by approximately 13%, erasing about $500 billion in market value in a single day—the largest single-day drop since its IPO. The market was not punishing growth itself, but rather two structural issues occurring simultaneously: AI infrastructure investment caused free cash flow to turn negative for the first time, and the monetization capability of the AI search product itself is lower than the traditional search it is replacing.

First, looking at the cash flow level. Alphabet generated $42.3 billion in operating cash flow in the third quarter, but capital expenditures surged to approximately $51.4 billion during the same period, resulting in a free cash flow deficit of $9.07 billion, exceeding market expectations. The company maintained its full-year capital expenditure guidance of $195 billion to $205 billion, with the vast majority directed toward data centers, servers, networks, and self-developed TPU chips. Investments are expected to remain high next year as well. This is a typical 'invest-first, harvest-later' structure: revenue is growing, but cash outflows precede revenue generation.

What truly unsettled the market was the second layer of issues. In the third quarter, Google Search advertising revenue was approximately $63.3 billion, up 12% year-over-year, with the growth rate slowing compared to the previous quarter. Chief Business Officer Philipp Schindler acknowledged on the earnings call that searches generated in AI Mode still have lower monetization levels than traditional search. This statement transformed a long-standing concern among investors into a fact confirmed by management: Google is redefining its core advertising product with AI, and the new product's ability to generate profit has not yet caught up.

The mechanism is not complex. The monetization model of traditional search is highly mature—users input keywords, relevant ads are displayed at the top of the results page, and search terms with clear purchase intent hold extremely high value for advertisers. AI search, however, provides an integrated, complete answer. There is currently no clear solution for where to place ads, how many to show, or how to do so without damaging user experience. More critically, AI answers themselves require computing power consumption, which further compresses the profit margin per search.

This creates a dilemma: failing to expand AI search means users will be diverted to conversational products like ChatGPT and Claude; expanding too quickly directly erodes the advertising revenue with the highest profit margins. Editor Kim Yoo-min of The Core summarized this situation as the paradox of AI search—defensive expansion and self-cannibalization are happening simultaneously.

The reason the market reacted so differently to Alphabet and Microsoft lies in the different pressure structures they bear. Microsoft is also investing heavily in AI data centers, but its third-quarter capital expenditures combined with finance leases totaled $45.2 billion, below market expectations, and free cash flow remained positive at $18.6 billion. More importantly, Microsoft does not have a core revenue line as weighty as Alphabet's search advertising that is being directly rewritten by its own AI products.

Sources:The Core(더코어)

Research

Reddit Forces Login: In the AI Era, Data Transforms from a Public Resource into a Priced Asset

Topic · Reddit强制登录政策Material
2026-11-02 12:29 GMT+8

The American online community Reddit is closing a door it has maintained for approximately twenty years. Steve Huffman, CEO of Reddit (United States), announced that the platform will pilot mandatory login requirements in select countries outside the United States over the coming months. Posts that were previously viewable without registration will now require users to create an account. A global rollout timeline and the interface displayed to non-logged-in users who click on post links have not yet been determined. Huffman acknowledged that this represents a significant personal shift for someone who has long valued an open internet, but he emphasized that it is a necessary decision for the platform and its business.

The primary force driving this decision is data collection by AI companies. Reddit hosts a vast accumulation of user-generated product reviews, life experiences, and professional discussions, which hold immense value for AI firms seeking to learn from authentic human language and experiences. The issue lies in the fact that some enterprises and automated tools scrape posts on a large scale without permission. Reddit has filed lawsuits against Anthropic and Perplexity, alleging unauthorized access to data, and has restricted access to Old Reddit. Huffman stated that most unauthorized data access occurs when users are not logged in; limiting access for non-members makes it more difficult for automated scrapers to operate—a judgment made by the company itself, though its actual effectiveness remains to be seen.

However, Reddit does not intend to sever its data relationship with AI companies entirely. In 2024, Reddit signed contracts granting data access rights to OpenAI and Google for post data. The core distinction in strategy is that unauthorized scraping is blocked, while data supply under formal contracts continues. User conversations that were once freely available to everyone are transforming into commercial assets that AI companies must pay to acquire.

This transition coincides with changes in Reddit's revenue structure. Financial reports for the third quarter of 2026 showed a significant decline in traffic originating from search engines, particularly among non-logged-in users and general website visitors. Huffman revealed that since October, average weekly visits driven by search engines have decreased by over one million. The spread of AI search services may be a contributing factor—previously, users would search on Google and then directly visit Reddit posts to find answers; now, AI synthesizes information from multiple websites and provides answers directly within search results or chat interfaces, reducing the necessity of visiting original pages. However, Reddit itself has not attributed the traffic decline solely to AI search.

A more critical economic reality is that Reddit's revenue does not depend uniformly on all visitors. According to the company, app users and daily active logged-in users contribute over 80% of overall monetization. Compared to anonymous visitors, logged-in users are easier to target with precise advertising and are more likely to return to the platform repeatedly. For Reddit, the commercial value of maintaining a core group of logged-in users far outweighs simply expanding the total number of visitors. Mandatory login therefore serves two goals simultaneously: preventing unauthorized data outflow and converting more users into monetizable logged-in identities.

Sources:The Core(더코어)

Research

Conservative Q-Learning: An Algorithmic Framework for Addressing Value Overestimation in Offline Reinforcement Learning

Verified 2026-11-03 00:06 GMT+8

Long-term reading · 《Conservative Q-Learning for Offline Reinforcement Learning》(2020)

A key challenge in applying reinforcement learning to the real world is directly utilizing pre-collected datasets without interacting with the environment. However, standard off-policy reinforcement learning methods often suffer from value overestimation due to distribution shift between the dataset and the learned policy, particularly when handling complex and multimodal data distributions. To address this issue, researchers from the University of California, Berkeley, and Google Research proposed the "Conservative Q-Learning" (CQL) algorithm. The core idea of this algorithm is to learn a conservative Q-function such that the expected value of the policy under this Q-function is lower than its true value, thereby preventing overly optimistic estimates caused by out-of-distribution actions.

CQL achieves this goal by adding a simple Q-value regularization term to the standard Bellman error objective. This method not only theoretically proves to produce a lower bound on the current policy's value but can also be integrated into policy learning processes with theoretical improvement guarantees. In practical applications, CQL requires adding fewer than 20 lines of code to existing deep Q-learning and actor-critic implementations. Experiments show that in both discrete and continuous control domains, CQL significantly outperforms existing offline reinforcement learning methods, typically improving final returns by 2 to 5 times, with particularly outstanding performance when learning from complex and multimodal data distributions. For researchers and engineers looking to learn effective policies from static data without interacting with the environment, the paper "Conservative Q-Learning for Offline Reinforcement Learning," published in 2020, provides a robust and easy-to-implement solution.

Sources:《Conservative Q-Learning for Offline Reinforcement Learning》(2020)

Research

Berkshire Hathaway Shareholder Letter 1977: Why Return on Equity Is More Important Than Earnings Per Share?

Verified 2026-11-03 00:06 GMT+8

Long-term reading · 《Berkshire Hathaway Shareholder Letter 1977》(1977)

In the 1977 Berkshire Hathaway shareholder letter, Warren Buffett delves into the correct standards for measuring management's economic performance. He criticized most companies for simply defining "record" earnings as a new high in earnings per share (EPS). Buffett pointed out that because companies typically increase their equity base year after year, if a company's equity capital increases by 10% while EPS grows by only 5%, such management performance is not particularly noteworthy. He argued that a more appropriate measure is the return on equity capital (Return on Equity). In 1977, Berkshire's operating return on beginning-of-year equity capital was 19%; although EPS grew by 37%, the beginning capital also increased by 24%, making the EPS growth appear less impressive than it seemed on the surface. This viewpoint emphasizes that investors should focus on the efficiency of capital usage rather than merely the growth of absolute profit figures.

Additionally, Buffett elaborated on the philosophy of insurance business operations in the letter, particularly regarding the importance of "tailwinds" versus "headwinds." He noted that in the insurance industry, even if some major mistakes are made, overall performance can still be quite satisfactory; whereas in the textile industry, even exceptionally excellent management yields only meager profits on average. This reveals a core investment principle: choosing businesses in favorable industry environments (tailwinds) is more critical than relying solely on superior management capabilities. He cited an example where the entire industry raised prices significantly in 1976 to offset disastrous underwriting results from 1974-75, making 1977 a beneficiary year. However, he also warned that as inflation and social inflation cause costs to rise by approximately 1% monthly, if rates cannot increase at the same pace, underwriting profits will shrink. Therefore, identifying turning points in industry cycles and adjusting strategies accordingly is crucial.

Finally, Buffett discussed the advantages of indirectly holding quality businesses through stocks. Using his investment in Capital Cities Communications as an example, he pointed out that directly purchasing the assets owned by the company might cost twice as much as the stock market investment and would not provide the same level of management. Through non-controlling stock investments, Berkshire could obtain the operational results brought by excellent management while avoiding the burden of control responsibilities. This strategy of "non-controlling interests" allows investors to enjoy long-term value created by outstanding management without interfering in daily operations. This concept challenges the traditional assumption that control inevitably leads to better outcomes, demonstrating that minority equity investments can be an effective way to obtain high-quality commercial returns at the right price.

For instance, suppose an investor is evaluating two technology companies. Company A has had an average annual EPS growth of 15% over the past five years, but its net asset scale expanded by 20%; Company B has an average annual EPS growth of 8%, but its net assets expanded by only 2%. According to Buffett's logic, despite Company A's faster EPS growth, Company B has higher capital efficiency, and its improvement in return on equity better reflects the true economic performance of management. Investors should be wary of companies that drive EPS growth by issuing large amounts of new shares or accumulating retained earnings, and instead look for enterprises that generate higher returns on a smaller capital base.

Sources:《Berkshire Hathaway Shareholder Letter 1977》(1977)

Research

You’re all caught up in this view

Sign in / Sign up
ReadingResearchRadarInvestment framework

The comparison with Meta reveals another path for AI strategy. Meta's advertising revenue grew 26% year-over-year in the third quarter, far exceeding Google's 11%. Excluding payments made to external parties such as Apple, the scale of advertising revenue for the two companies is now close. Institutions such as MoffettNathanson have drawn parallels between Meta's early monetization difficulties with Reels and Google's current situation: Reels did indeed drag down advertising growth rates upon launch, but Meta subsequently converted user time into revenue through algorithmic optimization. However, there is a key difference in this analogy—Meta uses AI to improve the efficiency of its existing advertising system, whereas Google faces AI changing the way the advertising system operates itself.

For AI industry investors, this set of data points to a judgment framework: the winner of the AI race may not necessarily be the company advancing technology the fastest, but rather the one that can complete the switch to new monetization models while maintaining the profitability of its legacy business. The overall growth rate of the advertising market has an upper limit; Madison and Wall have noted that current double-digit growth is difficult to sustain long-term. When the AI capital expenditures of Google, Meta, and Amazon all rely on advertising cash flows to support them, any slowdown in advertising growth will simultaneously amplify investment pressure and transformation anxiety.

The applicable boundaries of this mechanism also need to be marked. A single quarter of negative free cash flow may reflect investment pacing rather than a deterioration in long-term profitability; Schindler's statement acknowledges the current gap, not permanent structural damage; the Reels analogy suggests that the monetization gap may be bridged by technological iteration. But regardless of the speed of bridging, the tension between AI expansion and advertising monetization has become an unavoidable core variable in Alphabet's valuation narrative.

As a balancing measure, Reddit plans to revamp the private browsing mode of its app, aiming to limit data scraping while preserving a degree of anonymous experience. The company states that confirming login status is sufficient, without needing to verify users' real identities. However, whether this policy will genuinely improve user experience remains uncertain—if new users who stumble upon posts via search find the login process cumbersome, it could inadvertently suppress new traffic growth.

Reddit's case is not isolated. As AI companies utilize publicly available internet information to train models, content platforms attempt to protect the economic value of their own data; this tension is reshaping internet access rules. A portion of cyberspace that was once freely open is becoming an area requiring payment to enter, gated by login thresholds and commercial contracts.

For readers hoping to understand the underlying logic of value investing, rereading the Berkshire Hathaway 1977 Shareholder Letter has extremely high reference value. It not only clarifies misconceptions about financial indicators but also provides profound insights into judging industry cycles and selecting equity structures. It is recommended to start reading with the sections on "return on equity" and "insurance underwriting cycles," which best reflect the mature form of Buffett's early investment philosophy.