Econbrowser Blogger Menzie Chinn: Four Recession-Dating Methods Yield Different Answers for Germany in 2025–26
Economic data for Germany in 2025–26 present a seemingly contradictory set of signals: employment numbers and hours worked are declining, yet real GDP is growing strongly. In a post published on November 15, 2026, Econbrowser blogger Menzie Chinn compared four different methods for dating recessions in Germany, finding that they yielded different answers for the same period.
The first method is from ECRI (The Conference Board's Economic Cycle Research Institute). The second is from the German Council of Economic Experts (GCEE), which follows the methodological framework of the U.S. National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) and the Centre for Economic Policy Research (CEPR), dividing economic cycles into periods of expansion and contraction. The third is Laurent Ferrara’s 2019 method, which relies on GDP and industrial production data, using the Bry and Boschan algorithm to identify peaks. The fourth is Chinn’s own calculation based on pure employment data, primarily drawing from national accounts with minor reference to household surveys.
Chinn’s core argument is that it is difficult to argue Germany is in a recession given the backdrop of strong GDP growth. GDP-based methods (the GCEE and Ferrara) did not classify 2025–26 as a recession, whereas the pure-employment measure indicated contraction. The Ifo Institute’s nowcast released on November 6 showed that Germany’s Q4 GDP grew by 0.62% quarter-on-quarter, further supporting a judgment of expansion rather than contraction.
However, the source text only displays the differences in classification results among the various methods; it does not explain the economic reasons for the coexistence of falling employment and rising GDP, nor does it provide a comparison of the historical accuracy rates of these methods. Chinn’s conclusion relies on the premise that GDP growth will continue—if growth slows while employment continues to deteriorate, the classification conclusions could reverse. Additionally, Ferrara’s chronology predates the pandemic, and Chinn assumed in his graph that its 2020 dates matched those of ECRI, which is itself an unverified processing assumption.
Sources:econbrowser.com