AMD's Alleged Circular Financing Reveals a Structural Vulnerability Across AI Chip Companies
Short-seller Hunterbrook published a report titled "Bank of AMD" alleging that the AI chip company has run an extensive customer-financing-and-investing operation featuring "all of the circular financing of Nvidia, but without the margins or pricing power." A separate Hunterbrook story claimed AMD delivered updated chip firmware to multiple blacklisted Chinese entities. AMD said the reports didn't properly represent its business, but shares fell almost 10% on the news.
The circular financing thesis is not new. Chip companies invest in their customers, who then use those funds to buy chips from the same companies. Revenue looks strong, but a meaningful portion is self-reinforcing rather than driven by independent end-demand. The analogy to the telecom bubble of the early 2000s is that vendors extended credit to customers who used it to buy vendor equipment, inflating apparent demand until the cycle broke.
What makes the AMD case specifically interesting is the margin differential. Hunterbrook's core claim is that AMD replicates Nvidia's circular financing structure but lacks the same pricing power and margins. Nvidia commands premium pricing and has historically maintained wider gross margins, giving it more room to absorb the inefficiency of circular deals. AMD operates at thinner margins, meaning the same financing structure consumes a larger share of its economic value. If a customer's ability to pay depends on the vendor's own investment, the revenue quality is structurally weaker when margins are thinner.
The China dimension adds a second vulnerability. Like Nvidia, AMD sells chips to Asian neocloud operators that serve China's big tech companies. New US government export control rules put those revenues at risk. Hunterbrook's separate claim about firmware delivered to blacklisted Chinese entities, if substantiated, would compound regulatory exposure beyond what export controls alone create.
Broader market behavior supports the concern without proving it. Big Wall Street investment firms that promised in August to provide approximately $500 billion in loans for data centers have yet to dispense a single dollar, according to the Wall Street Journal. Nvidia's interim CEO Colette Kress signaled she intends to dial back Jensen Huang's aggressive dealmaking, which included a record 121 investments through Nvidia and NVentures in 2026. Anthropic's IPO went off better than expected, yet across the AI industry, a lot of people are selling on the news.
The strongest objection to the circular financing thesis is that genuine end-demand may be growing fast enough to outpace the self-reinforcing component. If AI compute demand is real and expanding independently of vendor financing, then circular deals are a convenience rather than a dependency. The telecom analogy breaks if the underlying use case generates sufficient standalone economics to sustain the cycle without vendor support.
The conditions under which this thesis matters most: when export controls tighten further, when margin compression makes circular deals unaffordable, when interim management at major chip companies reduces dealmaking pace, or when data center loan commitments remain unfunded for extended periods. Each of these would test whether revenue reflects genuine demand or capital recycling. None have yet triggered a full cycle break, but the directional signals are visible in the market's reaction to the Hunterbrook report itself.
Sources:newcomer.co