UK Investigatory Powers Tribunal Rules Home Office Must Confirm Apple Encryption Backdoor Order
The UK court rejected the government's national security secrecy claim, forcing disclosure of the order that led to the removal of iCloud Advanced Data Protection in the UK.
The UK Investigatory Powers Tribunal, an independent court overseeing surveillance orders under the Investigatory Powers Act (IPA), ruled on Thursday that the UK Home Office must confirm it served Apple with a Technical Capability Notice (TCN) requesting weakened encryption. The judge rejected the government's argument that disclosing the existence of the order would damage national security, although the ruling noted that not every detail of the order needs to be made public.
The TCN prompted Apple to disable its iCloud Advanced Data Protection (ADP) feature for users in the UK last February. ADP provides end-to-end encryption for stored data, meaning even Apple cannot access the files. While the existence of the notice was already known, the Home Office had repeatedly refused to officially confirm or deny it. This ruling forces the government to admit the action but does not compel it to reverse the request, meaning UK users will continue to lack access to ADP for the immediate future.
Liberty, a UK privacy group that initiated the legal challenge on behalf of two British citizens, called the decision a "victory for transparency." Akiko Hart, Director of Liberty, stated, "This case is about privacy and how we keep our personal data safe. In a digital age, end-to-end encryption gives us control over our personal information and the freedom to communicate securely." Jurgita Miseviciute, Head of Public Policy at Proton, welcomed the ruling as a win for transparency but criticized the IPA itself, saying, "There’s no such thing as a backdoor to encryption that only lets the good guys in."
Apple has previously stated that it "never built a backdoor or master key" to any of its products or services and "never will." The company confirmed that iMessage and FaceTime remain end-to-end encrypted globally, including in the UK. Privacy groups including Liberty and Privacy International announced they will continue to challenge the UK government's power to issue these orders in the first place. A final hearing on this broader constitutional question is expected in 2027.