ReadingResearchRadarInvestment framework
Sign in / Sign up
← Back to reading
NewsMaterial3 min readDisconfirmAI Editorial

Sebastian Pasch, Head of End User Services at Smith+Nephew: The Challenge for Enterprise AI Assistants Lies Not in Models but in Knowledge

Smith+Nephew piloted Ritual agent and ChatGPT concepts before purchasing Moveworks to launch Ellie, an AI assistant for IT services. Sebastian Pasch, the company's Head of End User Services, argues that the true challenge is not AI technology itself, but ensuring self-service knowledge is accurate and accessible while managing user expectations for ChatGPT-style instant answers.

2026-11-17 19:36 GMT+8

Medical device manufacturer Smith+Nephew employs 18,000 people. Its Head of End User Services, Sebastian Pasch, has followed a complete path from building in-house to buying off-the-shelf solutions, shifting from technological optimism to pragmatic focus on knowledge management during the deployment of enterprise AI assistants. He initially determined that the internal search experience could no longer meet employee expectations—staff no longer accept Google-style lists of search results; instead, they expect direct answers to specific questions, similar to those provided by ChatGPT.

Smith+Nephew first attempted using the Ritual agent but found it still required teams to manually program workflows. Pasch argued that understanding human language had already been solved by AI and should not remain a problem requiring repeated programming efforts. The company then turned to ChatGPT and built its own proof of concept, but quickly realized the technology was far more complex than it appeared from the outside. Consequently, they decided to abandon the in-house build and purchase a mature product instead.

One key factor in choosing Moveworks was the availability of a referenceable peer case. Pasch noted that they consulted with Honeywell and observed the practical effectiveness of their AI assistant, which had been running for five years. Honeywell had progressed from early BERT models to ChatGPT architectures, providing Smith+Nephew with confidence. Another consideration was that ServiceNow was then negotiating to acquire Moveworks; since Smith+Nephew was already a ServiceNow user, this promised closer integration between the two platforms once the deal was completed.

Sign in / Sign up
ReadingResearchRadarInvestment framework

Upon launch, Smith+Nephew selected IT services as its first scenario. Pasch’s explanation was straightforward: IT knowledge had accumulated significantly over years of service desk operations, giving them confidence in the quality of their service knowledge. However, he pointed out that knowledge for self-service scenarios differs from that intended for IT professionals—you cannot simply hand generic instructions meant only for technical experts to ordinary users.

After the AI assistant named Ellie went live, it received positive feedback from over 80% of users, exceeding Pasch’s own expectations. Every message in the conversation includes thumbs-up and thumbs-down buttons, allowing users to express satisfaction directly. However, not everyone embraced it: some employees stated they did not want to use AI and insisted on following original processes. This resistance became more pronounced when the company disabled redundant email notifications and required staff to obtain information exclusively through Ellie.

Another type of negative feedback stemmed from mismatched expectations. Despite all communications clearly labeling the tool as an IT support assistant—Ellie, the first stop for employee IT queries—some users asked HR or procurement questions. When these were not answered, they left poor ratings. Pasch attributed this to consumer experience inertia: people assume that wrapping a chat interface around a system makes it a universal AI, whereas enterprise assistants rely on carefully constructed knowledge bases capable of answering only covered questions.

For other enterprises wishing to deploy similar systems, Pasch offered three pieces of advice: First, clarify the knowledge base beforehand, ensuring the organization knows exactly what knowledge the AI should consume, and that self-service content is accurate and easy to understand. Second, avoid tool sprawl by selecting solutions that can handle multiple tasks within a single platform. Third, establish a pipeline of use cases, starting with those that are easy and quick to implement.

Smith+Nephew’s expansion strategy validates the third recommendation. The company plans to expand along knowledge dimensions—directly integrating existing financial, procurement, and other knowledge from the ServiceNow platform into Ellie. Pasch stated that since the IT scenario proved viable, hundreds of use cases have lined up, with various departments eager to be next. They decided to prioritize the 'low-hanging fruit' first.

Sources

  • diginomica.comdiginomica↗
Continue researching →