ReadingResearchRadarInvestment framework
Sign in / Sign up
← Back to reading
Long-term reading2 min readDisconfirmAI Editorial

Risk Revisited: Why Volatility Is Not Risk, and the Future Is Unpredictable but Manageable

In the 2014 memo "Risk Revisited," Howard Marks, founder of Oaktree Capital Management, reexamines the nature of investing.

Verified 2026-11-16 21:46 GMT+8

In the 2014 memo "Risk Revisited," Howard Marks, founder of Oaktree Capital Management, reexamines the nature of investing. He first challenges the academic definition that equates "volatility" with "risk." Marks states: "Volatility is the academic’s choice for defining and measuring risk." He argues that most investors do not truly fear volatility but rather permanent loss (permanent loss). Volatility is merely temporary fluctuation; as long as an investor holds through it, recovery is often possible. Permanent loss, however, is irreversible and may result from investors selling during downturns due to lost conviction, time horizon constraints, or financial urgency, or from fundamental deterioration in the investment itself.

Secondly, Marks discusses the unknowability of the future. He emphasizes: "Given the near-infinite number of factors that influence the future, the great deal of randomness present, and the weakness of the linkages, it’s my solid belief that future events cannot be predicted with any consistency." Since the future cannot be precisely predicted, risk cannot be a priori quantified. However, this does not leave investors helpless. Marks proposes that while we cannot know exactly what will happen, we can perceive the range of outcomes and their likelihoods. Therefore, "the future should be viewed not as a fixed outcome that’s destined to happen and capable of being predicted, but as a range of possibilities and, hopefully on the basis of insight into their respective likelihoods, as a probability distribution."

For modern readers, this theory provides a clear mental framework. Consider an investor facing a high-volatility technology stock portfolio; traditional views might suggest reducing volatility to "manage risk." But according to Marks's logic, if the companies within the portfolio have sound fundamentals and the volatility stems solely from market sentiment, then such volatility is not true risk. Conversely, if a company faces value destruction due to technological obsolescence, even stable stock prices imply significant risk. Thus, key risk management lies not in smoothing curves but in identifying factors leading to permanent loss and constructing a probability distribution model capable of withstanding multiple possible scenarios.

Sign in / Sign up
ReadingResearchRadarInvestment framework

"Risk Revisited" was written by Howard Marks in 2014. It is suitable for investors seeking to move beyond simple technical indicators to deeply understand the essence of risk. Readers are advised to start with chapters distinguishing "permanent loss" from "volatility" to develop probabilistic thinking in an uncertain future.

Sources

  • oaktreecapital.com《Risk Revisited》(2014)↗
Continue researching →