Reuters Columnist Klement: Analysts Called for 'Long' Before Two Previous Bubbles; AI Stocks Are Reenacting History
Klement compares the distribution of Wall Street analysts' recommendations in the late 1990s and before the 2008 crisis, finding that the overwhelming bullishness mirrors current coverage of AI stocks, raising the question of how this current rally will end.
Reuters columnist Joachim Klement shared a discovery he is particularly proud of: he compiled data on Wall Street analysts' recommendations at the peak of the late-1990s tech bubble and on the eve of the 2008 global financial crisis. He found that recommendations at both times were severely skewed toward bullish positions—none issued sell warnings to investors. He views this degree of imbalance itself as a signal worth noting.
This observation offers an alternative angle for identifying bubbles beyond valuation ratios. Previous analyses have argued that the current expansion relies too heavily on a single engine by examining the share of IT contribution to GDP growth, while academic models have attempted to decompose stock prices into expected dividends, expected returns, and rational bubbles. Klement focuses on another layer: when sell-side analysts are overwhelmingly bullish at a bubble's peak and their recommendations lack sell warnings, this itself constitutes a market sentiment signal—it does not directly tell you whether assets are overvalued, but it suggests that independent verification steps in the pricing process may have failed.
Klement draws a parallel between this pattern and current market coverage of AI stocks, pointing out that the same imbalance is being reenacted as bad news accumulates. His core question is not whether the bubble will burst, but how this current rally will conclude—with a bang or a whimper. He himself provides no answer. It should be noted that this is an attribution argument proposed by Klement based on chart observations, rather than an independently verified predictive model; the fact that analyst recommendations are overwhelmingly bullish may partly stem from conflicts of interest inherent in the sell-side business model, and its reliability as a warning signal depends on whether this behavior is independent of other market factors.