ProfitScore Market Extremes Index Reads 98/100: SSRN Paper Author John McClure Advocates Stress Testing Over Predicting the Top
John McClure’s paper ranks valuation, profitability, and leverage across six dimensions to synthesize an index; the current reading of 98/100 sits at the 99th percentile of its own history. His core argument is not to predict a market top, but rather: when multiple independent indicators simultaneously reach extremes, portfolio managers should stress-test scenarios involving margin compression, multiple contraction, and simultaneous equity-bond declines to determine whether expected returns are sufficient to bear those risks.
In his SSRN-published paper "Priced to Perfection," John McClure constructs a six-component composite index that ranks U.S. stock market valuation, profitability, and leverage levels individually before averaging them, yielding the ProfitScore Market Extremes Index. As of August 2026 data, the index reads 98/100, placing it at the 99th percentile of its own historical record. In the abstract on Quantpedia, McClure explicitly states: The related inputs and limited history of extreme events for this composite index constrain its effectiveness as a forecasting tool—but portfolio decisions need not rely on predicting the market top.
The index's core mechanism hinges on profit margin assumptions. The S&P 500's price-to-sales ratio currently stands at 3.78x, approximately 77% higher than the dot-com bubble peak, while the P/E ratio of 27x is actually lower than the 29x seen then. McClure argues that this gap is almost entirely supported by today's abnormally high profit margins—margins that are 89% higher than during the internet era. This implies the investment thesis relies heavily on a single assumption: that current margin levels will persist. Structural improvements might support higher profitability, but even partial normalization would weaken earnings per share unless revenue growth is sufficient to offset it. If multiples contract simultaneously, these two effects will compound.
Relative valuations are equally unsettling. The CAPE yield exceeds the 10-year TIPS yield by only 0.03 percentage points, the lowest equity risk premium recorded in the TIPS era. McClure acknowledges this spread is an imperfect measure of expected equity compensation, but it does raise the threshold for accepting equity risk: investors require a convincing earnings-growth outlook to justify bearing additional uncertainty. Meanwhile, margin debt growth has outpaced the market itself by 17 percentage points, constituting a potential source of forced selling.