ReadingResearchRadarInvestment framework
Sign in / Sign up
← Back to reading
NewsMaterial4 min readDisconfirmAI Editorial

Independent Analyst Richard Windsor: Nvidia Has Played All Its Cards; Market's Underreaction Implies at Least 65% Upside

Richard Windsor, founder of Radio Free Mobile, analyzes Nvidia's FQ3 2027 earnings report: The company is addressing the confidence crisis following Jensen Huang's departure through better-than-expected results, raised guidance, expanded share buybacks, and a commitment to return all free cash flow. Windsor argues that Nvidia has exhausted the buffer space accumulated over the past two to three years, leaving only gross margin recovery as its final card. With the market responding with only a 1.3% gain, this underreaction constitutes an upside potential of at least 65%.

2026-11-18 14:32 GMT+8

In its first full earnings quarter after Jensen Huang's departure, Nvidia has deployed almost every available tool to restore confidence. Richard Windsor, founder of the independent semiconductor research firm Radio Free Mobile, points out that the actual performance and forward guidance for FQ3 2027 constitute a systematic effort to rebuild trust: Revenue reached $115.8 billion and EPS was $2.70, significantly exceeding market expectations of $109.0 billion and $2.48; FQ4 guidance of $126 billion to $134 billion (midpoint $130 billion) also surpassed the consensus estimate of $125.4 billion. However, the market responded with only a 1.3% price increase, which Windsor believes represents exactly where the opportunity lies.

The short-term pressure on gross margins is the most easily misinterpreted aspect of this earnings report. Windsor explains that the current decline in gross margins stems from rising component costs; Nvidia has already addressed this by raising prices, but the pass-through effect takes time. Consequently, gross margins for the next two quarters will be slightly below normal levels, but are expected to recover to an average of 72% to 73% in fiscal year 2028. Windsor emphasizes that even without Jensen Huang, Nvidia retains extraordinary pricing power, and the recovery of gross margins is the last card he sees being played before FY 2028.

The core mechanism supporting Windsor's bullish view is the expectation management system Nvidia has built over the past two to three years. Because products sell out 12 months in advance, the company has high visibility into the next three months and therefore historically chooses to provide guidance below actual expectations, leaving room to beat estimates and raise guidance later. Windsor believes that Nvidia has now used up this reserve for FY 2028, as it raised revenue growth expectations from 70% year-over-year to 75% year-over-year. This appears to him as the utilization of that buffer—meaning the company no longer retains a safety margin but has laid all its cards on the table.

Sign in / Sign up
ReadingResearchRadarInvestment framework

Capital allocation is another signal of confidence. Nvidia has received authorization for a $227.3 billion share buyback program and has committed to returning all of its free cash flow to shareholders, rather than just the majority as in the past. Windsor specifically notes that Nvidia's buybacks differ from those of most companies: many companies buy back shares and then reissue them as stock options to employees, meaning shareholders receive no actual benefit. In contrast, Nvidia's fully diluted share count has been falling for some time, and there is no reason to believe this trend will reverse. Combined with the fact that the current stock price remains 33% below its all-time high, the effectiveness of the buyback program is further amplified.

Regarding valuation, Windsor forecasts FY 2028 revenue of $720.7 billion and EPS of $16.88, both higher than the consensus estimates of $692 billion and $15.74. His model includes $500 billion in debt to reflect the company's new commitments and increases the discount rate by 300 basis points (equivalent to a 40% valuation discount) to compensate for transition risks in the post-founder era. Even so, he arrives at a target price of $265 per share. Windsor explicitly states that even if Nvidia's best days are behind it, the current price still offers at least 65% upside.

The condition under which this argument is most likely to fail is if gross margin recovery falls short of expectations. Windsor himself admits that growth will slow very rapidly after FY 2028, and his valuation already discounts for this. However, he also points out that while the Nvidia board has had material shortcomings over the past 33 years, RFM Research concludes that the board is not as passive as the market assumes and will be more effective than expected in implementing governance repairs. The new chairman also appeared on the earnings call, doing his best to reassure the market that Nvidia can still thrive without plans to bring Jensen Huang back, but the company can still flourish.

Windsor discloses at the end of his article that he is increasing his position in Nvidia, stating that now is a good time to take the other half of his position. His core logic is: Nvidia has played all its cards, yet the market has given a indifferent response. This underreaction itself constitutes the opportunity.

Sources

  • radiofreemobile.com↗
Continue researching →