ReadingResearchRadarInvestment framework
Sign in / Sign up
← Back to reading
NewsMaterial2 min readDisconfirmAI Editorial

Independent Mobile Analyst Richard Windsor: Apple Must Create an Exclusive AI Agent, or Its Ecosystem Premium Will Be Eroded

Independent mobile industry analyst Richard Windsor argues that with third-party AI agents such as ChatGPT, Claude, and Meta Muse already occupying the top ten spots on the App Store, if Apple fails to launch a top-tier exclusive agent, user preference will shift from the smartphone ecosystem to the agents themselves. This shift will make it difficult to sustain the tension between its 36.7x forward price-to-earnings ratio and its 6% growth rate.

2026-11-20

The App Store charts have already indicated the direction of travel: Meta's Muse, ChatGPT, and Claude are firmly entrenched in the top ten, OpenAI is expanding the functionality of Dots, Anthropic is testing Duet, Google has launched Tasks, and SpaceX is heavily pushing Grok Bot. None of these agents belong to Apple.

Richard Windsor believes this is a replay of the script seen fourteen years ago when the mobile ecosystem first emerged. At that time, numerous products competed for the central position in users' digital lives, and ultimately only iOS, Android, and WeChat survived. The difference now is that last time, Apple and Google were challengers with nothing to lose; this time, they are incumbents facing challenges, making them naturally more risk-averse because their existing massive businesses make it difficult for them to let go.

Windsor's core mechanism is this: if the agent on the device eventually performs most digital life services for the user, user preference will shift from the smartphone ecosystem to the agent itself. Since agents like Dots, Muse, and Duet can provide equivalent quality of service across all ecosystems, users will then question why they should continue to pay a premium for Apple. He concludes that Apple must create a top-tier agent and ensure it is available exclusively on Apple products.

However, Apple's current situation makes this task urgent. Windsor bluntly states that Siri is clear evidence of Apple's third-rate AI capabilities, and the fact that Apple is only now posting job openings for roles related to proactive agents shows just how far behind it is. He believes that while users have not yet chosen device ecosystems based on agents—meaning cross-device stickiness among iPhone, Mac, and Watch can temporarily maintain the overall ecosystem cohesion—this buffer will disappear once the agent becomes the true center of digital life.

Sign in / Sign up
ReadingResearchRadarInvestment framework

Windsor also points out that Apple's current lack of exposure to AI actually provides it with a safe-haven status, as market sentiment toward AI trading is cooling. However, he believes this is insufficient to support its premium valuation: Apple shares trade at a 36.7x forward P/E ratio, nearly four times that of Nvidia, while offering only a 6% growth rate. In his view, there is much better value available elsewhere.

Sources

  • radiofreemobile.com↗
Continue researching →