Howard Marks' "The Calculus of Value": Analyzing the Psychological Game Between Intrinsic Value and Price
In the memo "The Calculus of Value" released in 2025, Howard Marks, founder of Oaktree Capital, delves into the core challenge of investing: how to define an asset's "intrinsic value" and how it interacts with market "price."
In the memo "The Calculus of Value" released in 2025, Howard Marks, founder of Oaktree Capital, delves into the core challenge of investing: how to define an asset's "intrinsic value" and how it interacts with market "price." Marks points out that value is not an objectively existing number but the result of subjective judgment, rooted in the asset's "earnings power." This earnings power includes not only current returns but also the potential to generate future cash flows, representing a combined effect of tangible assets, intangible assets, and management skills.
However, market prices do not always reflect this rational calculation. Marks emphasizes, "While value may seem theoretical and ephemeral, price is concrete." Prices are determined by daily investor votes, reflecting market consensus, which is often heavily influenced by optimistic or pessimistic sentiments. When investor sentiment is high, prices may far exceed value; conversely, they may fall below value. Therefore, the essence of investing lies in finding opportunities in the deviation between value and price, rather than simply chasing price fluctuations.
To address this uncertainty, Marks proposes an action framework based on valuation levels, which he calls "INVESTCON." This framework ranges from Level 6 (Stop Buying) to Level 1 (Short Selling), advising investors to gradually adjust positions according to the extremity of market valuations. For example, when market valuations are high and investor behavior is optimistic, adopting INVESTCON 5—reducing aggressive holdings and increasing defensive holdings—is a prudent approach. This method reminds us that long-term success depends on accurate assessment of fundamentals and clear awareness of market psychology.
For readers seeking to deepen their understanding of value investing, "The Calculus of Value" provides a clear mental model. Author Howard Marks wrote this piece in 2025, suitable for investors attempting to identify true value in noisy markets and understand mechanisms of price deviation. It is recommended to start with chapters on "Sources of Value" and "Price Formation Mechanisms," integrating the INVESTCON framework to consider one's own asset allocation strategy.