ReadingResearchRadarInvestment framework
Sign in / Sign up
← Back to reading
NewsMaterial3 min readDisconfirmAI Editorial

Groundwork Collaborative CEO Lindsay Owens: How Loyalty Programs Became Pricing Weapons

Lindsay Owens, CEO of Groundwork Collaborative and author of "Gouged," explained on Bloomberg's At The Money podcast the dual-profit mechanism of loyalty programs: companies use purchase history data to impose loyalty penalties (reducing discounts) on loyal customers, while simultaneously bundling and selling customer data. She cited Kroger as an example, noting that 95% of its transactions are tied to a loyalty program, with alternative profit businesses accounting for 30% of net operating income, much of which comes from selling customer data.

2026-11-19 03:00 GMT+8

Fixed-price tags have existed in the United States for nearly 150 years. Lindsay Owens, CEO of Groundwork Collaborative and author of the new book Gouged: The End of a Fair Price—and What That Means for Your Wallet, argues on Bloomberg’s At The Money podcast that this system is facing a threat of extinction. Electronic shelf labels and algorithmic pricing make prices more volatile, while personalized pricing presents different prices for the same product to different consumers. She characterizes this shift as a new frontier in pricing, and indeed, a new frontier for corporate profiteering.

For investors, the most concrete mechanism lies in how loyalty programs serve two distinct profit lines simultaneously. The logic of the loyalty penalty, as described by Owens, is that once a company masters your regular purchasing patterns, it determines you are a certain customer and ceases to push offers and discounts. She cites two examples: a Washington Post reporter who requested data from Starbucks received a 55-page report showing that discounts decreased over time; and a Wired magazine reporter who requested data from the McDonald’s app received a file of about 500 pages containing a lifetime attrition score. The reporter’s score was zero, meaning McDonald’s determined he would never switch to Burger King.

The second profit line is data resale. Owens cites Kroger as an example: 95% of the company’s transactions are tied to its loyalty program, and its alternative profit business accounts for 30% of its net operating income, with a significant portion coming from the sale of customer data. This means that while consumers believe they are enjoying member discounts, they are simultaneously acting as input variables for pricing optimization and raw materials for data products. Owens characterizes loyalty programs as a double-edged sword.

Sign in / Sign up
ReadingResearchRadarInvestment framework

The implication of this mechanism for retail investment analysis is that customer data is no longer just an operational efficiency tool, but an independent profit center. When a retailer includes data monetization in its income statement, its valuation logic must consider both product gross margins and data revenue. However, this also introduces structural risks—if the loyalty penalty mechanism is widely recognized by consumers, it could trigger a brand trust crisis. Owens lists cases where consumer backlash changed corporate behavior: in the mid-1990s, Coca-Cola’s CEO proposed installing thermometers in vending machines to raise prices on hot days, but withdrew the plan after strong opposition from media and consumers; Delta’s pricing partnership with Fetcherr was exposed by Groundwork Collaborative, leading Southwest and American Airlines to attack the move, prompting Delta to roll back some plans; and Instacart issued a statement within two weeks promising to stop using relevant practices after research assisted by Groundwork Collaborative was exposed.

On the regulatory front, Owens mentions that rulemaking completed by the U.S. Federal Trade Commission at the end of the Biden administration has banned drip pricing in two sectors: short-term lodging and event ticketing. Airbnb and Vrbo must now display the total price including cleaning fees, and concert ticket buyers can see the full price including handling fees when hovering over a seat. New York City also implemented a click-to-cancel rule about a week ago, requiring businesses operating in the city to provide cancellation methods identical to those used for registration.

It should be noted that Owens’ arguments are a mix of normative judgments and factual statements. The 30% alternative profit ratio is her restatement of Kroger’s business structure, not a directly quoted public disclosure line item; the loyalty penalty cases come from individual journalists’ data requests and do not constitute systematic evidence; and the characterization of corporate profiteering as a new frontier is a value judgment. However, the behavioral logic of loyalty penalties—reducing discounts once a company masters purchasing patterns—is consistent with economic theories of price discrimination. For investors evaluating retail companies, treating data monetization as an independent profit line and viewing loyalty penalties as a brand risk factor provides actionable insights derived from this mechanism.

Sources

  • ritholtz.comThe Big Picture↗
Continue researching →