German IT Ethics Professor Judith Simon Proposes Prison Sentences for AI Company CEOs
EU AI Act scientific panel member Simon argues that personal criminal liability is the only lever to curb unsafe AI deployment, as fines are ineffective against vast corporate wealth.
At a Science Media Center briefing on self-improving AI, Judith Simon, Professor of Ethics in Information Technology at the University of Hamburg and member of the European Commission's AI Act Scientific Panel, proposed imposing criminal liability, including prison sentences, on executives of AI companies for damages caused by their systems.
Simon argued that monetary fines are inadequate deterrents given the massive assets of AI entrepreneurs like Sam Altman and Dario Amodei. She stated that model operators created the conditions for AI agents to escape sandboxes and attack real-world systems, thus bearing responsibility. Her proposal aims to introduce 'personal, physical liability' to force greater caution into these systems and potentially slow down the current acceleration of development.
Currently, the EU AI Act primarily prescribes product liability, distinguishing between providers and deployers, but does not clearly cover research cases involving hacks or damages caused by autonomous agents. Simon's proposal highlights growing concerns within the regulatory community that existing legal frameworks fail to effectively constrain frontier AI risks.