Federal Reserve Bank of New York Research: Post-Pandemic Workers Systematically Underestimate Job-Finding Probability, with Largest Bias Among Youth and Low-Education Groups
Researchers at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York compared consumer expectation surveys with actual labor market data, finding that post-pandemic workers' expected probability of re-employment remained persistently below actual rates (53.0% vs. 58.8%). This bias was concentrated among workers under 30 and those without a college degree; simultaneously, workers overestimated their risk of job loss, with those having more than two years of tenure expecting a job-loss probability more than double the actual rate.
In research published on November 16, 2026, a team from the Federal Reserve Bank of New York—including Richard Audoly, Ivy Chen, Miles Guerin, and Rachel Schuh—systematically compared subjective estimates from the Survey of Consumer Expectations (SCE) regarding "the likelihood of finding a new job within three months if you lost your current job" with actual re-employment rates tracked in the Current Population Survey (CPS). The results showed high alignment between expectations and reality from 2014 to 2019: the average expected three-month re-employment rate was 55.5%, compared to an actual rate of 57.2%. However, a persistent gap emerged after 2020: from 2022 to the present, the actual re-employment rate has averaged 58.8%, while worker expectations have dropped to 53.0%.
This pessimism is not evenly distributed. Workers aged 30 and older and those with a college education saw little change before and after the pandemic, consistently remaining slightly below actual rates (by about 4 to 6 percentage points). In contrast, workers under 30 experienced a significant reversal: pre-pandemic they were optimistic, with expectations exceeding actuals by 6.3 percentage points; post-pandemic they turned pessimistic, underestimating their re-employment probability by 3.0 percentage points. Workers with a high school diploma or less exhibited the largest negative bias, with expectations 7.5 percentage points lower than actuals. The authors note that while rising youth unemployment is a frequently discussed topic, overly negative expectations themselves may exacerbate the downbeat employment outlook for new labor market entrants.