Econbrowser Blogger Menzie Chinn: Term Spread Inversions Barely Help Predict Australian Recessions
Econbrowser blogger Menzie Chinn finds that the 10-year minus 3-month term spread has negligible predictive power for Australian recessions across ECRI, Melbourne Institute, and modified Sahm rule chronologies, with pseudo-R2 below 0.14 over 1986–2026 and a coefficient of the wrong sign. Even restricting to the pre-pandemic period, which raises pseudo-R2 to as high as 50%, the spread still retains the wrong sign.
Econbrowser blogger Menzie Chinn has tested whether the 10-year minus 3-month government bond term spread predicts Australian recessions. His answer: not really, even using alternative recession chronologies.
The standard yield curve hypothesis holds that an inversion—when short-term rates exceed long-term rates—signals that markets expect economic contraction ahead. Chinn's question was whether this logic applies to Australia.
He tested the 10-year minus 3-month spread against three different recession definitions: the Economic Cycle Research Institute (ECRI) peak-to-trough dates, the Melbourne Institute's chronology, and a modified Sahm rule using a 0.75 percentage point unemployment threshold (the level the Reserve Bank of Australia has suggested). The unemployment-based Sahm rule is available only from February 1978 onward.
The results are stark. Over the 1986–2026 window, none of these recession chronologies are predicted with a pseudo-R² greater than 0.14, and the coefficient on the spread is opposite of what the standard story would require. Restricting the sample to the pre-pandemic period raises the pseudo-R² to as high as 50% for the ECRI or Melbourne Institute chronologies, but the spread still retains the wrong sign.
Chinn also notes a complication with the Sahm rule itself. Using the 75 basis point threshold, the rule would flag recessions in 2001 and 2009—years when neither total employment nor GDP declined on a sustained basis. This suggests that even the recession definition introduces noise into the Australian context.