Buffett's 2018 Letter to Shareholders: Why Investors Should Ignore Accounting Noise and Focus on Operating Earnings
In the 2018 letter to shareholders, Warren Buffett, Chairman of Berkshire Hathaway Inc., offers core guidance for investors evaluating corporate value: they should strip away short-term earnings volatility caused by accounting rule changes and instead focus on a company's actual operating performance. This perspective is essential for understanding long-term value investing.
In the 2018 letter to shareholders, Warren Buffett, Chairman of Berkshire Hathaway Inc., presented his core views on how investors should evaluate corporate value: they should exclude short-term profit fluctuations driven by changes in accounting standards and concentrate on the company's true operational capabilities. This philosophy is critical for understanding long-term value investing.
First, Buffett noted that new Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) require unrealized capital gains or losses on stock portfolios to be included in current earnings, resulting in "wild and erratic swings" in the "bottom line." He wrote in the letter: "We have always believed that mark-to-market changes in Berkshire produce what I call 'wild and erratic swings' in the 'bottom line.'" These fluctuations do not stem from deterioration or improvement in the underlying businesses but are immediate reflections of market sentiment on asset valuations. Therefore, he advised readers: "Focus on operating earnings; pay almost no attention to various types of gains and losses." This means that when evaluating a business, one should filter out market noise and assess whether its core operations generate stable and growing cash flow.
Second, based on this logic, Buffett announced the abandonment of "book value per share" as the primary metric for measuring the company's progress. He argued that this metric has lost relevance because Berkshire has transitioned from a company primarily holding tradable stocks to a conglomerate whose main value lies in operating enterprises. He explained in the letter: "In fact, the annual change in Berkshire’s book value—last appearing on page 2—is a measure that has lost the relevance it once had." As the company's structure evolved, book value could no longer accurately reflect the true intrinsic value of numerous non-listed subsidiaries, whereas operating earnings more directly demonstrate management's capital allocation efficiency.