ReadingResearchRadarInvestment framework
Sign in / Sign up
← Back to reading
NewsMaterial3 min readDisconfirmAI Editorial

Ben Carlson: Stocks Outperform Bonds in 85% of Historical Decade Windows, but High Probability Does Not Equal Certainty

Ritholtz Wealth Management portfolio manager Ben Carlson uses rolling ten-year data since 1926 to quantify the win rate (85% chance of exceeding 5% annualized returns) and return asymmetry of stocks relative to bonds, discussing what this historical probability implies for allocation decisions against the backdrop of U.S. equities having delivered extraordinary returns for nearly 18 consecutive years.

2026-11-19 23:48 GMT+8

A reader asked Ben Carlson a question on stage at the Bogleheads conference: Which will have better returns over the next decade, stocks or bonds? The subtext of the question was that the U.S. stock market has risen for almost 18 years; surely mean reversion is due, right?

Carlson, a portfolio manager at Ritholtz Wealth Management, did not answer directly with a yes or no. Instead, he pulled up rolling ten-year return data for the S&P 500 and five-year U.S. Treasuries dating back to 1926. The results showed that stocks outperformed bonds in most decade windows, but not 100% of the time.

He approached the quantification of this issue from another angle: using the current government bond yield of approximately 5% as a benchmark line, stocks have historically exceeded this level in 85% of all ten-year time frames. If you hold a broad-based stock index fund for ten years, there is an 85% probability that your annualized return will exceed the coupon income of Treasury bonds during the same period.

But frequency is only half the story. Carlson further compared the magnitude of difference in performance when each asset class wins: when stocks outperform bonds, the margin of victory is far greater than when bonds outperform stocks. This means that even if you occasionally pick the wrong side, your losses are relatively limited; whereas when you pick the right side, the gains are significantly higher.

Based on this asymmetry, Carlson’s conclusion is that if he had to place a bet in Las Vegas on who would win over the next decade, he would pick stocks every time because the odds are in his favor. However, he simultaneously emphasized that high probability does not equal certainty. That 15% of failure periods were not pleasant for investors. He cited a metaphor from Bill Bernstein at the conference: holding the market for the long term makes you the house because the odds are in your favor; but even the house loses sometimes.

Sign in / Sign up
ReadingResearchRadarInvestment framework

Carlson did not frame this issue as an either/or choice. He pointed out clearly that the good news is you do not need to bet on one or the other. Holding bonds is not suitable for everyone, but fixed income can provide a cushion when you lose a hand or two. Although the current 5% yield level does not guarantee that bonds will definitely earn 5%, the starting yield is a good approximation of future returns—meaning that even if interest rates continue to rise, once the dust settles, expected returns could actually be higher. His advice is essentially: take on stock risk when probabilities are favorable, while using bonds to provide a margin of safety when truly needed.

Sources

  • awealthofcommonsense.comA Wealth of Common Sense↗
Continue researching →