Meta denies Muse read private messages without permission; reporter disagrees
The two sides tell conflicting stories and the original posts could not be checked; whether Muse's permission layer holds remains unresolved.
ImportanceLocalEvidenceE3 inspectableWrite-upQuick
Meta denies that its AI assistant Muse read a user's private Mac messages without permission; the reporter involved stands by his account.
Inc. columnist Jason Aten wrote that Muse read his messages while full disk access was switched off, and that when he asked why, Muse said it was syncing his device notifications. Meta communications VP Andy Stone replied on X that Muse can only read messages if the user turns on both full disk access and the messages connector. David Singleton, an executive at Meta's superintelligence lab, added that reading requires three separate permission layers plus macOS protections, and said the AI had simply given a wrong explanation of what happened.
Stone's original X post and Aten's Inc. column could not be checked directly; the details above come from IT Home's October 1 report. This is the second overreach dispute around Muse: a YouTuber previously said a Muse mistake exposed his home address, and Meta is investigating that complaint.