LeituraPesquisaRadarFramework de investimento
Entrar / Cadastrar
← Voltar para a leitura
NotíciasTópico · 伯克利AI批改争议Material3 min de leituraEditorial DisconfirmAI

UC Berkeley Math Professor Richard Borcherds: Grading for Accuracy Is Meaningless After AI Can Solve Problems

Richard Borcherds, a mathematics professor at the University of California, Berkeley, argues that grading student assignments for accuracy has lost its meaning now that AI can solve complex mathematical problems, including the Navier-Stokes existence and smoothness problem. He currently grades only on whether assignments are submitted in full, while admitting uncertainty about whether he should still encourage young people to major in mathematics.

2026-10-28 22:55 GMT+8

Richard Borcherds, who currently teaches mathematics courses at the University of California, Berkeley, has made a decision that has attracted attention in academia: he no longer grades students' math assignments for accuracy, but only for whether they are submitted in full. In an interview with The Daily Californian, he explained his logic: the use of AI has become inevitable, and since machines can solve problems, it is meaningless to pay teachers to check whether students' answers are correct. He admitted that this is not a particularly good system, but there is currently no alternative.

This judgment is based on two specific points. First, Borcherds has long observed that many students use AI to complete their assignments and often receive top marks. Second, OpenAI recently announced that its AI models had solved a series of mathematical problems, including the Navier-Stokes existence and smoothness problem. Based on these two points, Borcherds drew a broader inference: if AI continues to advance at its current pace, there will be nothing human mathematicians can do in a few years that AI cannot do better.

However, abandoning grading for accuracy does not mean the problem is solved. The UC Berkeley campus tested several AI detection tools, including Turnitin and Rumi, and ultimately concluded that they were not suitable for standardized use. A case from a university in Australia illustrates the unreliability of technical detection: the university's AI detector recorded nearly 6,000 suspected violations related to AI in 2024, but 90 percent of them were later proven to be false alarms. When detection tools themselves are unreliable, the dilemma facing teachers is not whether to use AI detection, but what else they can do besides abandoning grading.

Entrar / Cadastrar
LeituraPesquisaRadarFramework de investimento

The deeper question that arises is: if AI can solve all mathematical problems, how valuable is mathematics as a discipline and profession? Borcherds admits that he is no longer sure whether he should encourage young people to choose mathematics as a major. He mentioned that five years ago, at the beginning of the AI boom, mathematics was considered one of the safest career choices. He even asked ChatGPT this question, and ChatGPT's answer was that it didn't know what would happen in the future either. The 722 professional papers released by OpenAI have caused widespread unease in the scientific community, and the newly established Association for Human Mathematics is trying to protect the status of mathematics as a human endeavor.

It should be noted that Borcherds' inference is built on an unproven premise: that AI will continue to advance at its current pace. This is a prediction, not an observed fact. Borcherds' position is directed at the specific assessment method of grading for accuracy, rather than asserting that learning mathematics itself is meaningless. His decision reflects a pragmatic choice by a professor under existing tool conditions, rather than a final judgment on the future of mathematics education as a whole.

Fontes

  • t3n.de↗
Tópico

伯克利AI批改争议

加州大学伯克利分校数学教授、菲尔兹奖得主Richard Borcherds宣布停止按正确性批改学生作业,转而仅检查是否完整提交。这一决定源于AI能力的飞跃:OpenAI近期宣称其模型已解决包括Navier-Stokes存在性与光滑性问题在内…

4 etapas2 peçasAtualizado 2026-11-09 01:54

Como chegamos aqui

  1. 2026-10-25《纽约邮报》报道,Richard Borcherds因发现学生普遍使用AI完成作业并获得高分,决定停止按正确性批改作业。nypost.com ↗
  2. 2026-10-26Borcherds进一步透露,由于在线考试平均分异常升高且无法有效识别AI作弊,他已将评估重心转向禁止电子设备的线下考试。nypost.com ↗
  3. 2026-10-29德国科技媒体t3n.de报道,Borcherds指出OpenAI已解决Navier-Stokes问题等数学难题,因此按正确性评分已无意义。t3n.de ↗

O que ainda está indefinido

  • 伯克利大学或其他高校是否会出台统一的AI作业评估标准,还是继续维持教师自主决定的现状?
  • 随着AI在数学领域能力的进一步提升,数学专业的招生规模和课程设置将如何调整以应对潜在的职业替代风险?
  • 是否有更可靠的AI内容检测方法或评估模式(如口试、过程性评估)被证明能有效平衡学术诚信与学习激励?

Também nesta thread

  • Richard Borcherds, Mathematics Professor at the University of California, Berkeley: AI Renders Homework Grading Meaningless2026-11-08
Ler o tópico completo →
Continuar pesquisando →