読書リサーチレーダー投資フレームワーク
ログイン / 新規登録
← 読解に戻る
ニューストピック · 瑞典国债安全港地位重大2 分で読めるDisconfirmAI 編集部

Investment Commentator Klement: Banque de France Study Shows Swedish Government Bonds Have Surpassed US Treasuries as Safe Havens

Joachim Klement cites a 2026 working paper from the Banque de France, which measures safe-haven scores through asset correlations during risk-averse periods. The study finds that Swedish government bonds have replaced US Treasuries at the top of the government bond safe-haven ranking, while the US dollar retains its status as the most prominent safe-haven asset across all categories. Klement points out that lower national debt levels correlate with higher safe-haven status for government bonds, with US Treasuries being a significant exception to this rule.

2026-11-11 15:01 GMT+8

US Treasuries are losing their traditional status as a safe haven. A new study by the Banque de France, which measured asset correlations during periods of heightened risk aversion, found that Swedish government bonds have surpassed US Treasuries in safe-haven scores, with Norwegian government bonds following closely behind. Investment commentator Joachim Klement analyzed this working paper by Burban et al. in a November 11, 2026 Substack article, noting that the findings confirm his assessment made earlier this year: investors are losing trust in US Treasuries but retain confidence in the US dollar itself.

The study's methodology involves measuring correlations between various assets during periods of rising risk-averse sentiment to determine which assets truly function as safe havens. The scope covered government bonds, investment-grade corporate bonds, currencies, gold, silver, crude oil, and Bitcoin. Klement specifically noted that Bitcoin, crude oil, and silver lack safe-haven characteristics; while gold possesses safe-haven attributes, its ranking falls significantly below most government bonds or the US dollar.

In the government bond ranking, Swedish government bonds take the top spot, followed by Norwegian government bonds in second place, with US Treasuries trailing behind. Klement summarized a general rule: the lower a country's debt level, the more its government bonds are viewed by investors as safe-haven assets. US Treasuries represent the most notable exception to this rule—despite the massive scale of US debt, its Treasuries have long enjoyed top-tier safe-haven status. At the bottom of the ranking are French, South Korean, and Belgian government bonds, whose safe-haven performance is comparable to that of Japanese corporate bonds.

ログイン / 新規登録
読書リサーチレーダー投資フレームワーク

Regarding corporate bonds, investment-grade bonds from Sweden, Norway, and Australia perform similarly to German Bunds or Swiss Eidgenossen in terms of their safe-haven functions.

More noteworthy is the divergence between the US dollar and US Treasuries. Klement pointed out that while the US dollar remains the asset with the most pronounced safe-haven characteristics among those examined, the safe-haven score for US Treasuries is continuously declining. This trend mirrors the situation during and after the Global Financial Crisis. In other words, investor confidence in the US dollar itself has not waned, but trust in US Treasuries as a safe-haven asset is eroding.

This finding has direct implications for asset allocation. If safe-haven scores reflect the actual performance of assets during risk-averse periods, then equating US Treasuries with traditional hedging tools like the US dollar or gold is becoming untenable. Klement believes this study provides empirical support for his March assessment: the safe-haven attributes of the US dollar and US Treasuries are diverging, and investor confidence in the two is no longer equivalent.

ソース

  • klementoninvesting.substack.com↗
トピック

瑞典国债安全港地位

【背景】长期以来,美国国债被视为全球金融市场的终极“安全港”。然而,法国央行(Banque de France)2026年发布的工作论文显示,在风险规避时期,瑞典国债已取代美国国债位居政府债券安全港排名首位。该研究通过测量资产相关性发现,一…

5 ステップ1 件更新日 2026-11-15 14:54

経緯

  1. 2013-01-21ING Investment Management发布报告,基于过去十年数据分析,认定瑞典是全球最安全的政府债券市场,主要得益于其低债务率(低于40% GDP)和经常账户盈余。wealthbriefing.com ↗
  2. 2025-04-13瑞典国债管理局(Riksgälden)局长Karolina Ekholm接受《Svenska Dagbladet》采访表示,受特朗普关税政策影响,投资者开始将瑞典国债视为“安全港”,需求远超供给,导致瑞典借贷成本低于德国。dagensps.se ↗
  3. 2025-11-11Robin J Brooks撰文分析“便利收益”(convenience yield),指出瑞典因极低的政府债务水平(33% GDP)正成为顶级安全港目的地,其便利收益已降至瑞士以下。robinjbrooks.substack.com ↗

未解決の問題

  • 瑞典国债市场规模相对较小,其流动性是否足以长期承载大规模全球避险资金流入?
  • 美国国债安全港地位的下降是暂时性的市场情绪波动,还是由债务可持续性问题导致的结构性转变?
  • 除了低债务率,还有哪些制度性或地缘政治因素促使投资者在危机时刻优先选择北欧而非传统的美债或德债?
トピック全文を読む →
リサーチを続ける →