LectureRechercheRadarCadre d'investissement
Connexion / Inscription
← Retour à la lecture
ActualitésSujet · 维基媒体AI版权立场Matériel2 min de lectureRédaction DisconfirmAI

Wikimedia Files Amicus Brief in NYT v. OpenAI Case: Argues AI Training Is Fair Use, But Substitutive Outputs Require Licensing

The Wikimedia Foundation proposed a middle-ground legal framework in the landmark AI copyright lawsuit, distinguishing between transformative training and infringing output substitution.

2026-10-30 17:00 GMT+8

The Wikimedia Foundation, the nonprofit operator of Wikipedia, filed an amicus brief on Friday in the landmark copyright lawsuit brought by The New York Times against OpenAI and Microsoft, proposing a nuanced legal distinction. The organization argues that large language models (LLMs) should be legally protected when training on copyrighted work under the doctrine of fair use, but that chatbots which regurgitate articles to users—effectively substituting for the original content—should require licensing.

Stephen LaPorte, General Counsel at the Wikimedia Foundation, stated that an overly black-and-white ruling could threaten the sustainability of free knowledge. He warned that a victory for publishers might allow copyright holders to "gatekeep" even innovative and transformative uses of their work, while a victory for AI companies could constitute "a green light to snub licensing terms and fragment the flow of knowledge between human authors and audiences."

The filing highlights Wikipedia's dual role as both a critical data source for AI training and a platform undermined by AI-driven traffic diversion. Wikimedia notes that its websites have become "one of the most critical sources of data for all artificial intelligence and machine learning training," yet these same systems siphon away visitors, weakening the communities that maintain the sites. Furthermore, Wikimedia argues that services like ChatGPT violate copyright by reproducing text licensed under Creative Commons without adhering to the license's attribution and share-alike requirements.

Despite these concerns, the Foundation acknowledges the utility of LLMs for Wikipedia editors, who use them to fight vandalism, detect copyright violations, and identify articles needing improvement. By advocating for a split ruling, Wikimedia seeks to balance the development of open-source technologies with the protection of the collaborative human knowledge ecosystem.

Connexion / Inscription
LectureRechercheRadarCadre d'investissement

Currently, The New York Times alleges that OpenAI infringed its copyright by scraping its website to build training datasets. OpenAI and Microsoft contend that using LLMs constitutes fair use, with OpenAI describing regurgitation as a "rare bug." The Wikimedia brief offers the court a third path, emphasizing the difference between transforming data for training and simply replacing the original work in user interactions.

Sources

  • theverge.comThe Verge↗
Sujet

维基媒体AI版权立场

维基媒体基金会(Wikimedia Foundation)在《纽约时报》诉OpenAI及微软的版权诉讼中提交法庭之友意见书,提出“训练与检索分离”的折中方案。该美国非营利组织主张:利用受版权保护的内容训练大语言模型(LLM)若产生“全新且不…

4 étapes1 piècesMis à jour 2026-11-01 14:36

Comment on en est arrivé là

  1. 2026-01-15维基媒体基金会宣布与亚马逊、微软、Meta、Perplexity和Mistral AI等公司达成商业数据协议,加入Wikimedia Enterprise计划,以应对大规模数据抓取带来的服务器成本压力。futurism.com ↗
  2. 2026-03-26英文维基百科更新政策,禁止编辑使用生成式AI撰写或重写文章,仅允许在严格人工审核下用于翻译或润色,西班牙维基百科则完全禁止LLM使用。engadget.com ↗
  3. 2026-10-29维基媒体基金会向纽约南区联邦法院提交动议,请求获准在In re: OpenAI, Inc. Copyright Infringement Litigation案中提交法庭之友意见书。courtlistener.com ↗

Ce qui reste non résolu

  • 法院是否会采纳维基媒体提出的‘训练’与‘检索’二分法,还是倾向于支持原告或被告的单一标准?
  • 维基媒体的CC BY-SA 4.0许可证要求是否会被法院视为强制性的合规基准,影响其他开放知识库的法律地位?
  • AI公司在面对此类法律不确定性时,是否会加速转向专有数据源或进一步收紧对公共网络内容的抓取策略?
Lire le sujet complet →
Continuer la recherche →