LecturaInvestigaciónRadarMarco de inversión
Iniciar sesión / Registrarse
← Volver a la lectura
NoticiasTema · 伯克利AI批改争议Material2 min de lecturaEditorial de DisconfirmAI

Richard Borcherds, Mathematics Professor at the University of California, Berkeley: AI Renders Homework Grading Meaningless

Mathematics professor Richard Borcherds of the University of California, Berkeley, has publicly stated that grading mathematics homework is no longer meaningful due to students' widespread use of AI and its rapidly improving capabilities. He currently only checks for complete submission and admits uncertainty about whether he should still encourage students to major in mathematics.

2026-11-08 17:35 GMT+8

Richard Borcherds, a mathematics professor at the University of California, Berkeley, recently stated publicly that he no longer grades his students' homework. His reasoning is straightforward: students widely use AI to complete assignments, and AI capabilities are continuing to improve rapidly, making it impossible to assess students' true mathematical proficiency by checking the correctness of these submissions. He admitted that he currently only verifies whether assignments have been submitted in full, acknowledging that this is not an ideal system but noting there is no alternative available at present.

Borcherds's assessment is based on a specific observation: he has noticed that many students have long relied on AI to complete their homework and consistently achieve top grades. Meanwhile, OpenAI recently announced that its AI models had solved a series of mathematical problems, including the existence and smoothness problem for Navier-Stokes equations. From this, Borcherds concluded that if AI continues to advance at its current pace, there will soon be nothing human mathematicians can do that AI cannot do better.

This assessment also touches on more practical institutional realities. The University of California, Berkeley previously tested AI detection tools such as Turnitin and Rumi, ultimately determining they were unsuitable for standardized use. A case from an Australian university further illustrates the issue: that institution's AI detector flagged nearly 6,000 suspected cases of misconduct in 2024, 90% of which were later confirmed to be false positives. This means that attempting to distinguish between human-written and AI-generated work through technological means is currently unfeasible.

Iniciar sesión / Registrarse
LecturaInvestigaciónRadarMarco de inversión

Borcherds's stance thus extends to a more fundamental question: whether young people should still be encouraged to pursue mathematics as a major. He recalled that at the beginning of the AI boom five years ago, mathematics was considered one of the safest career choices. Now, even he is unsure how to advise. He even posed this question to ChatGPT, which replied that it, too, did not know what the future held.

It should be noted that Borcherds's claim that AI will surpass human mathematicians within a few years is a prediction, not an established fact. The specific scope and verification status of OpenAI's claimed solution to the Navier-Stokes problem have not yet received independent confirmation. Furthermore, the value of mathematics as a discipline—including understanding structure, the aesthetics of proof, and cross-domain modeling capabilities—is not entirely equivalent to problem-solving speed. Borcherds's position is closer to an honest acknowledgment of the current failure of assessment systems rather than a final verdict on the future of the field of mathematics.

Fuentes

  • t3n.de↗
  • heute.atHeute↗
Tema

伯克利AI批改争议

加州大学伯克利分校数学教授、菲尔兹奖得主Richard Borcherds宣布停止按正确性批改学生作业,转而仅检查是否完整提交。这一决定源于AI能力的飞跃:OpenAI近期宣称其模型已解决包括Navier-Stokes存在性与光滑性问题在内…

4 pasos2 piezasActualizado 2026-11-09 01:54

Cómo llegó hasta aquí

  1. 2026-10-25《纽约邮报》报道,Richard Borcherds因发现学生普遍使用AI完成作业并获得高分,决定停止按正确性批改作业。nypost.com ↗
  2. 2026-10-26Borcherds进一步透露,由于在线考试平均分异常升高且无法有效识别AI作弊,他已将评估重心转向禁止电子设备的线下考试。nypost.com ↗
  3. 2026-10-29德国科技媒体t3n.de报道,Borcherds指出OpenAI已解决Navier-Stokes问题等数学难题,因此按正确性评分已无意义。t3n.de ↗

Lo que aún está pendiente

  • 伯克利大学或其他高校是否会出台统一的AI作业评估标准,还是继续维持教师自主决定的现状?
  • 随着AI在数学领域能力的进一步提升,数学专业的招生规模和课程设置将如何调整以应对潜在的职业替代风险?
  • 是否有更可靠的AI内容检测方法或评估模式(如口试、过程性评估)被证明能有效平衡学术诚信与学习激励?

También en este hilo

  • UC Berkeley Math Professor Richard Borcherds: Grading for Accuracy Is Meaningless After AI Can Solve Problems2026-10-29
Leer el tema completo →
Continuar investigando →