Cowen, Author of 'Marginal Revolution,' Cites Security Researcher Saxe's Analysis: Labor Constraints in Cybercrime Explain Why AI Has Not Worsened Losses
Security researcher Joshua Saxe modeled and estimated that approximately 720,000 people are involved in the online criminal economy, with 90% engaged in scam and fraud call-center operations and only about 76,000 being hackers, most of whom work for governments. Criminal organizations are constrained by three factors: labor supply, law enforcement pressure, and the timeline for developing business models; consequently, AI has not yet caused a discontinuous surge in losses. Cowen recommended this analysis on 'Marginal Revolution.' Saxe also warned that 'the apocalypse will be slow-moving,' noting that the current period is a defender-dominant window for preparation.
Why have cybersecurity losses not worsened due to AI? This is the central unresolved question in current discussions on AI security policy. If AI indeed empowers attackers, why has there been no discontinuous growth in global cybercrime losses over the past few years? Tyler Cowen, author of 'Marginal Revolution,' cited an analysis by security researcher Joshua Saxe, offering an explanation rooted in the labor market.
Saxe’s modeling estimates that approximately 720,000 people are involved in the online criminal economy, with 90% engaged in scam and fraud call-center-type operations, some of them victims of human trafficking. Of the roughly 76,000 actual hackers, the vast majority work for governments; among the remaining few thousand criminal hackers, most are involved in ransomware. This implies that criminal organizations must base themselves in middle- and low-income countries, where they can pay lower wages and hire individuals with limited opportunities in the formal economy. Saxe wrote that people in the fields of AI safety and cybersecurity sometimes imagine their adversaries as their own 'Waluigi twins'—implicitly MIT graduates; in reality, cybercrime involves a lower-skill demographic.
Beyond labor supply, there are law enforcement constraints. Saxe pointed out that the larger the criminal organization, the more domestic and international law enforcement attention it attracts. Russia, Belarus, Colombia, and Ukraine have histories of weak rule of law, but when criminals scale up enough to attract international attention, they are often arrested while on vacation abroad. He examined the arrest outcomes of 152 named criminal enterprises, noting survivorship bias, but found that the vast majority faced legal consequences.