LectureRechercheRadarCadre d'investissement
Connexion / Inscription
← Retour à la lecture
SujetRédaction DisconfirmAIMis à jour 2026-11-21 22:38

Loyalty Penalty Pricing

6 étapes1 pièces6 Sources

The "loyalty penalty" is a pricing strategy where companies charge existing, loyal customers more than new ones for the same goods or services. This practice has evolved from simple price-walking in UK utilities and insurance to sophisticated algorithmic surveillance pricing in retail and tech. Groundwork Collaborative CEO Lindsay Owens describes it as a dual-profit mechanism: firms use purchase history to withhold discounts from sure customers while monetizing their data. Evidence spans from the UK Competition and Markets Authority's 2018 super-complaint identifying a £4 billion annual penalty across five markets, to US Federal Trade Commission studies on personalized pricing. The core disagreement lies between consumer advocates who view this as unfair exploitation of trust and behavioral biases, and some economic researchers who warn that strict bans on discriminatory pricing might inadvertently facilitate tacit collusion among firms, potentially raising overall prices. Regulatory responses are fragmented: the UK FCA banned price-walking in home and auto insurance in 2022, while US states like New York and Maryland have enacted disclosure requirements or restrictions on using personal data for higher food prices.

Comment on en est arrivé là

  1. 2017-11-24

    In November 2017, Citizens Advice published a report highlighting that 12.9 million UK households were paying a loyalty penalty in home insurance, with renewers paying up to 70% more than new customers.

    citizensadvice.org.uk ↗
  2. 2018-12-19

    In December 2018, the UK Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) responded to a super-complaint by Citizens Advice, estimating the total loyalty penalty across mobile, broadband, cash savings, home insurance, and mortgages at around £4 billion annually.

Connexion / Inscription
LectureRechercheRadarCadre d'investissement
gov.uk ↗
  • 2022-05-17

    In May 2022, a study in Frontiers in Psychology found that algorithmic price discrimination significantly increases consumers' perceived betrayal and lowers perceived price fairness.

    pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov ↗
  • 2024-09-06

    In September 2024, an FT Chinese column by HKU Business School researchers argued that banning discriminatory pricing in differentiated markets like insurance could lead to tacit collusion and higher prices, citing post-FCA ban price hikes in the UK.

    hkubs.hku.hk ↗
  • 2025-01-01

    In January 2025, the US Federal Trade Commission released initial findings from its surveillance pricing study, noting that algorithms can exclude regular customers from promotions based on inferred willingness to pay.

    epic.org ↗
  • 2026-11-18

    In November 2026, Bloomberg podcast 'At The Money' featured Lindsay Owens, who cited Kroger's 95% loyalty program transaction rate and explained how loyalty programs serve as vehicles for both withholding discounts and selling customer data.

    ritholtz.com ↗
  • Ce qui reste non résolu

    • Will the US Federal Trade Commission move from study findings to enforceable rules requiring disclosure of personalized pricing bases?
    • Do state-level laws in the US (e.g., Maryland, Connecticut) create a sufficient patchwork to deter national retailers from opaque surcharges, or will federal preemption be sought?
    • Can regulators distinguish between beneficial dynamic pricing (market-driven) and harmful individualized targeting without stifling innovation?

    Sources

    • citizensadvice.org.ukCitizens Advice↗
    • gov.ukUK Competition and Markets Authority↗
    • pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govFrontiers in Psychology↗
    • hkubs.hku.hkFT Chinese / HKU Business School↗
    • epic.orgElectronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC)↗
    • ritholtz.comBloomberg / Ritholtz↗

    Couverture dans ce sujet

    • Groundwork Collaborative CEO Lindsay Owens: How Loyalty Programs Became Pricing Weapons2026-11-19Actualités

      Lindsay Owens, CEO of Groundwork Collaborative and author of "Gouged," explained on Bloomberg's At The Money podcast the dual-profit mechanism of loyalty programs: companies use purchase history data to impose loyalty penalties (reducing discounts) on loyal customers, while simultaneously bundling and selling customer data. She cited Kroger as an example, noting that 95% of its transactions are tied to a loyalty program, with alternative profit businesses accounting for 30% of net operating income, much of which comes from selling customer data.