In October 2026, reporter Mary Randolph connected Meta's Muse and OpenAI's Dots to her real accounts during a move, naming them Mark and Sam, and conducted a week-long test of daily tasks. She asked researchers to help design testing methods, one of which was to see if the agents would proactively recommend products unrelated to user preferences.
The results were surprising. She asked Mark and Sam to use all their known personal information to suggest how to spend $50. Sam recommended a used book she had previously asked it to find—reasonable but mundane. Mark offered two suggestions: first, based on her Spotify collection, it recommended tickets to a January concert by Jess Williamson; second—and this happened seven times over three days—it pushed her to register for a Target membership and buy a lamp on sale. She did need a lamp, but she judged that Mark's recommendation stemmed from promotional content it read while browsing the Target website, rather than her personal needs.
Manuel Cherep, a doctoral student at MIT Media Lab who studies AI behavior, believes this discovery reveals a key issue: if merchants can convince agents that a product is worth buying, it could spawn a parallel economy driven by purchases made via AI assistants. His structural argument is that there are a limited number of mainstream model providers, and their training methods are highly similar; therefore, persuading one model is likely to persuade others simultaneously, thereby influencing many users who delegate decision-making to such models.
At Meta's Connect conference in September, Zuckerberg (the human one) stated that the company would eventually profit by charging small commissions on agent transactions. This means the platform itself has an economic incentive to encourage agents to facilitate purchases, and the agents' susceptibility to marketing aligns precisely with this business model.
Nikhil Singh, a computer scientist at Dartmouth College, points out that agent technology itself is not more advanced than chatbots; the true social difference lies in the speed and breadth of adoption. Pat Pataranutaporn, an assistant professor at MIT Media Lab studying human psychological responses to AI, focuses on: when agents have names, faces, and deep knowledge of users' lives, they easily transform from tools into friends.
The test also exposed platform exclusivity issues. When Randolph handed over her Facebook login credentials to Sam, Meta flagged Sam as a bot and temporarily locked her Instagram, Facebook, and WhatsApp. The two agents could not collaborate within the same ecosystem. Additionally, in a logic test designed by researchers—how to get to a car wash 100 feet away—Sam (running GPT-6 Astra) correctly answered to drive, noting the car needed to be washed too, while Mark suggested walking, reasoning that finding keys took longer than walking. Cherep said: People tend to treat agents as omniscient delegates, but like humans, they can also be misled.
William Overman, a doctoral student in AI safety at Stanford University, worries that people assume agents are omniscient, and combined with their ability to act, may make the boundary between human work and machine output increasingly indistinguishable. Randolph herself felt this encroachment—she is usually an analog person, calling a friend the week before moving to ask which wrench to buy; but during the test week, she found herself handing over more and more trivial matters to Mark and Sam.