LecturaInvestigaciónRadarMarco de inversión
Iniciar sesión / Registrarse
← Volver a la lectura
NoticiasTema · 美国公众AI负面看法Material3 min de lecturaEditorial de DisconfirmAI

Cross-Validation of Five Probability-Sampling Polls: American Negative Views on AI Are Robust and Cross-Partisan

Max Roser, author at Our World in Data, synthesizes five probability-sampling surveys from Pew Research Center, Gallup, Quinnipiac University Poll, Annenberg Public Policy Center, and Ipsos. The data reveals that regardless of question wording, negative views of AI among Americans consistently outweigh positive ones; Pew data shows this ratio expanding from approximately 2:1 in 2021 to over 5:1 by 2026.

2026-11-16 08:00 GMT+8

In 2026, five high-quality polls using probability sampling methods—Pew Research Center, Gallup, Quinnipiac University Poll, the Annenberg Public Policy Center, and Ipsos—asked U.S. adults about their views on artificial intelligence (AI) using different wordings, option sets, and collection modes. The direction of results was completely consistent: every survey found that more Americans held negative views of AI than positive ones.

This conclusion itself is not surprising, but its robustness is noteworthy. Poll wording does affect specific numbers: when a middle option is provided, a large share of respondents select it—37% chose the middle option in Pew’s 2026 survey—while the positive option’s share is compressed to just 9%. Consequently, absolute proportions across different surveys cannot be directly compared. However, all five surveys point unerringly in the same direction toward the same judgment: public concern about AI in the United States outweighs anticipation or excitement.

Pew’s data particularly illustrates the shift in trends. In the June 2026 survey, 52% of respondents said they were “more concerned than excited” about AI, while only 9% said they were “more excited than concerned,” a ratio exceeding 5:1. When Pew first asked this same question in November 2021, the ratio was approximately 2:1. Over these four-plus years, the gap between concern and enthusiasm has more than doubled.

Iniciar sesión / Registrarse
LecturaInvestigaciónRadarMarco de inversión

An Ipsos survey conducted in October 2026 further showed that when people hold strong feelings, the majority are negative: 17% considered AI an “extremely bad” thing for society, compared to just 2% who considered it “extremely good.” A Quinnipiac University Poll telephone survey from September 2026 touched upon the most extreme concerns: 73% of Americans believe AI poses a risk to human survival, with 38% expressing that they are very concerned.

This concern crosses partisan lines. Pew data shows that 56% of Democrats and 49% of Republicans are more concerned than excited about AI; in both parties, only about one in ten people are more excited than concerned. Anxiety regarding AI is not the exclusive emotion of any single political faction.

However, there is one area where results diverge from the above pattern: when asked about AI’s impact on personal life rather than society as a whole, the Ipsos survey found that 50% viewed it as a good thing and 49% as a bad thing, nearly splitting evenly. Yet even within this more personalized framework, strong feelings still lean negative—15% believed AI would be extremely harmful to them personally, versus only 3% who believed it would be extremely beneficial. In a Quinnipiac University Poll conducted in March 2026, 55% expected AI to cause more harm than good in their daily lives, while 34% expected more good than harm.

The core implication of this data set is that American public attitudes toward AI are not an illusion manufactured by questionnaire wording, but a stable pattern spanning methodology, time, and partisanship. If the AI industry hopes to win public trust, it faces not merely a public opinion issue that can be repackaged, but a widespread concern that has already taken root.

Fuentes

  • ourworldindata.orgOur World in Data↗
Tema

美国公众AI负面看法

美国公众对人工智能(AI)的负面看法已呈现稳健且跨党派的趋势。Our World in Data 综合 Pew、Gallup 等五家权威机构的概率抽样调查指出,无论问题措辞如何,认为 AI 弊大于利的美国人始终多于受益者;Pew 数据显示这…

7 pasos1 piezasActualizado 2026-11-18 18:31

Cómo llegó hasta aquí

  1. 2021-11-01Pew Research Center 首次询问美国人对 AI 的感受,当时“担忧多于兴奋”与“兴奋多于担忧”的比例约为 2:1。ourworldindata.org ↗
  2. 2026-03-09NBC News 民调显示,仅 26% 的选民对 AI 持正面看法,净好感度为 -20,低于特朗普和 ICE。cnet.com ↗
  3. 2026-05-13宾夕法尼亚大学安纳伯格公共政策中心(APPC)发布调查,65% 的美国人认为政府监管 AI “做得太少”,且支持联邦政府主导监管。annenbergpublicpolicycenter.org ↗

Lo que aún está pendiente

  • 科技巨头签署的非约束性自我监管协议能否实质性缓解公众对 AI 安全风险(如黑客攻击、存在性威胁)的担忧?
  • 随着 2027 年斯坦福 AI Index 正式发布,劳动力市场数据是否会进一步证实 AI 对初级职位的替代效应,从而加剧反 AI 情绪?
  • 美国国会或各州是否会响应民调中压倒性的监管诉求,出台具体的 AI 限制法案或数据中心建设禁令?
Leer el tema completo →
Continuar investigando →