David Rolnick, Associate Professor at the School of Computer Science, McGill University in Canada, and co-founder of Climate Change AI, recently put forward a core judgment at the "Green Computing Power and Climate Digital Technology" forum hosted by Taiwan's Ministry of the Environment during the United Nations COP31 period: When discussing AI and climate change, the real question is not "whether to use AI," but "what kind of AI should be used for what problem."
He uses the metaphor of "elephants and bees" to illustrate two directions in current AI development. Large generative models such as ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude are "elephants"—massive in scale, requiring large data centers, and primarily handling general tasks such as text generation, image synthesis, and code writing. The other type of AI is the "bee"—specialized models used for prediction, classification, optimization, and scientific computing, such as analyzing satellite imagery to identify land-use changes, predicting wildfire risks, or optimizing grid operations, which do not require support from large data centers.
Rolnick emphasizes a key distinction: these two types of AI are fundamentally different and cannot simply be understood as "shrinking a large model" to obtain specialized AI. Citing research cases, he points out that while large language models may have trillions of parameters, some climate application models only require millions of parameters—a difference of several million times. For specific scientific problems, smaller models can actually be more efficient.
His argument is that AI applications for many social issues should be a combination of a few "elephants" and multiple "bees." Most problems are solved by specialized small models, which improves efficiency while reducing unnecessary energy consumption. Taking the climate sector as an example, if the goal is to predict solar power generation for the next hour, what is needed is a prediction model combining meteorological and energy data, rather than a large language model.
Rolnick further criticizes a spreading deployment pattern: high-energy-consuming AI functions are preset into daily services. He cites Google Search's introduction of generative AI summary features as an example—users do not actively request generative AI summaries for every search, yet the system automatically generates them. He estimates that if billions of searches globally adopt this feature, the overall electricity consumption could be comparable to the residential electricity usage of a large city.
He believes the problem lies not with the power consumption of a single model, but with preset deployment. Generative AI should be prioritized for scenarios that truly require reasoning and content generation, rather than becoming the default solution for all applications. He suggests that AI development should adjust in several directions: promoting more medium-sized computing resources so users can use task-appropriate AI through personal computers or edge devices; increasing AI energy transparency so developers and users understand the energy costs of different tools, hardware, and tasks; and continuously improving the energy efficiency of models, hardware, and data centers.