Brian Sommer founded his first consulting firm during his junior year of college, and later worked at Arthur Andersen (the predecessor to Accenture). In an article published on November 5, 2026, he responded to a recurring question: Are consultants still indispensable? His answer is yes—but for reasons more specific than usual.
Sommer first acknowledges that the impact of AI on entry-level consulting work is real. Generative AI can parse billions of client documents to identify trends, summarize content, and structure data; it can draft consulting presentations and generate research reports. Algorithmic AI can rapidly process vast data sources to create financial and operational forecasts. More critically, ERP, HR, and financial accounting software vendors are using AI to automate implementation tasks—data cleansing, pre-configuring software, inserting regulatory requirements, and embedding industry-specific processes—tasks that previously required large teams of junior consultants and integrators.
But Sommer’s core argument is not that AI cannot do these things, but rather that what remains after AI completes them constitutes the true value of consulting. He illustrates this with two personal experiences: A professional he has known for years handed him an AI-generated 'result,' treating an extrapolated trend line as actual data—the absence of an audit trail pointing back to the source data should have been a massive red flag, yet she failed to notice. In another instance, a savvy financial analyst showed him AI-generated charts that looked visually impressive but had completely overlooked several subtle factors that needed to be considered.
Sommer believes this touches on the core difference between what AI does poorly and humans do well: thinking. AI developers like to claim that AI can reason, but this is not the same as deep, considered analysis, assessment, and the application of multiple perspectives. Humans can engage in critical thinking and incorporate unique angles that were not part of an AI’s original training data. While AI excels at re-solving old problems, one-off, weird, or unique matters fall outside its database, large language models, and training sets.
So who performs the novel work that AI cannot? Sommer’s answer is consultants. He describes how great consulting actually works: When facing a thorny client project, the best approach is to convene a group of senior consultants who understand the client, the industry, market trends, value creation, and organizational dynamics. This knowledge may be partially codified in the models used by AI tools, but certain elements—such as nuance—remain beyond AI’s capabilities.
He provides a specific mechanism: Great consultants know they might independently come up with only 80% of a good idea, but a team is needed to truly refine and expand that initial concept, pushing the 80% solution to a 95-97% level of excellence. This is why consultants socialize new ideas, concepts, and approaches with their peers. At Arthur Andersen, all matters required a 'second partner review' before being shared with clients. This process serves both as a quality check and character building: presenting your best idea to peers and superiors, watching it get dissected, is humbling. However, the key point is that the knowledge gained from these new inputs and perspectives can dramatically improve recommendations to the client.