Zvi Mowshowitz: OpenAI's New Model Spec Examples Are Too Simple to Teach Models How to Handle Truly Difficult Cases
AI commentator Zvi Mowshowitz, after a line-by-line comparison of OpenAI's new and old model specifications, points out that the new version relies heavily on examples structured as 'two extreme errors and one correct middle ground,' resulting in answers that are too certain. This approach fails to teach models or readers how to act when faced with genuinely ambiguous situations. He illustrates this ubiquity with specific examples such as ordering Thai food with peanut allergies, breeding Scottish Fold cats, and comparing FDR to Reagan, arguing that alignment specifications require difficult cases that 'make good law' rather than simple cases that merely confirm common sense.
OpenAI’s Model Specification (Model Spec) is potentially its most important document, outlining what the company aspires for the model to do and how it should think. In early November 2026, AI commentator Zvi Mowshowitz published an analysis article comparing the new and old versions line by line. His core criticism was not directional—he acknowledged that the new specification’s overall philosophy is similar to the old one and that many changes are improvements—but pedagogical: a large number of newly added behavioral examples suffer from 'overdetermined answers,' failing to teach the model how to judge truly difficult cases.
Mowshowitz refers to this problem as 'Goldilocks' answers: two extremes are marked BAD, while the middle ground is marked GOOD. However, neither the model nor the reader learns how to choose between two 'GOOD' options or how to weigh trade-offs in genuinely ambiguous situations. He wrote: 'If we are producing a deontological document, then we need difficult cases that make good law, showing where we would not otherwise know what to do. Easy cases do not make bad law, but neither do they make good law.'