Diamond Hill: How the Mortgage Lock-In Effect Creates Asymmetric Risk for MBS Investors
First Eagle's Diamond Hill team quantifies the US mortgage market's structural problem: 74.1% of outstanding loans carry rates below 6% while new mortgages exceed 7%, suppressing refinancing and extending the duration of agency MBS. The coupon composition of the Bloomberg US MBS Index has shifted from 32.1% to 37.4% for loans at 5% or above. The team argues that planned amortization class tranches within collateralized mortgage obligations offer more predictable cash flows than passthroughs under these conditions, while acknowledging that security selection and structural understanding remain essential.
Agency mortgage-backed securities behave differently from other fixed-income instruments when rates rise. A corporate bond's duration is fixed at issuance; a mortgage's effective duration stretches as homeowners decline to refinance, extending the life of the loan and the investor's exposure. Diamond Hill's November 2026 insight quantifies how extreme this asymmetry has become.
The Federal Housing Finance Agency's National Mortgage Database shows that as of the second quarter of 2026, roughly 74.1% of outstanding US mortgages carry an interest rate below 6%, with nearly half below 4%. Current 30-year fixed rates hover above 7%. This gap creates what the team calls a "golden handcuffs" effect: homeowners with legacy low-rate loans face substantially higher borrowing costs if they move, so they stay put. Existing home sales fell 5.5% in October 2026 to 3.75 million, the lowest activity level since August 2010.
The consequence for MBS investors is extension risk. When rates rise, prepayment slows, cash flows arrive later than expected, and the security's duration lengthens precisely when the investor would prefer it to shorten. The Bloomberg US MBS Index has underperformed asset-backed securities, investment-grade corporates, and commercial mortgage-backed securities during 2026's rate moves. The coupon composition data makes the structural shift visible: the share of index MBS with coupons of 5% or higher rose from approximately 32.1% in 2025 to 37.4% in October 2026, but lower-coupon mortgages still dominate the pool.